Applied Mathematics in the Medieval Era

During the Middle Ages, a significant application of mathematics was in trade and commerce—a timeless necessity. In Europe, traders primarily utilized Roman numerals, while Arab merchants employed a more sophisticated system known as the Hindu-Arabic numeral system. The key advantage they held was the inclusion of the number zero.

The absence of zero in the Roman numeral system hampered efficiency, whereas Arabian traders could execute calculations more effectively due to their numeral system's nuances.

Arabian Traders Arrive in Europe

When Arabian merchants reached the shores of Italy, local traders quickly recognized the benefits of adopting the Hindu-Arabic numeral system. However, the adoption was met with caution from political and legal authorities. The flexibility of the Hindu-Arabic numerals allowed for potential manipulation in written transactions, raising concerns.

For example, a trader might initially claim an item costs 16 currency units, only to later assert that the actual price was 91 units. While Arabian traders could discern such subtleties, the locals were less familiar with the numeral system's intricacies.

This concern was compounded by a more profound issue involving the concept of zero.

Why Was Zero Viewed Negatively?

Prior to this period, Europeans were unfamiliar with the concept of zero. Not only was the idea challenging for them to comprehend, but they were also morally unprepared to embrace its implications. For instance, zero played a crucial role in representing negative values, indicating debt in financial dealings, which at the time was regarded as ethically problematic.

The combination of these factors rendered the Hindu-Arabic numeral system—and particularly the number zero—unappealing in Europe.

The Emergence of Bans on Numbers

In the 13th century, authorities in Florence, Italy, enacted a ban on the use of Hindu-Arabic numerals for recording commercial transactions. This marked the onset of a series of debates and controversies that would span centuries.

Some mathematicians recognized the advantages of Hindu-Arabic numerals, particularly zero, while others staunchly opposed these innovations. The discourse surrounding negative numbers persisted well into the 19th century, revealing the contentious nature of mathematical advancement.

Lessons from History

Although we now take concepts like zero, negative numbers, and the Hindu-Arabic numeral system for granted, this narrative underscores the resistance they initially faced. The evolution of mathematics has often been fraught with contention.

For example, Hippasus of ancient Greece introduced the notion of irrational numbers, which was met with hostility, leading to his exile for challenging the accepted norms of his time.

Will History Repeat It?

Even though we may view the actions of our ancestors as misguided, the historical record illustrates humanity's intrinsic fear of change. Mathematics, being a human endeavor, is not exempt from this phenomenon. Thus, it is reasonable to anticipate that controversies will continue to surface in the field as it evolves.

If we find ourselves in a period devoid of mathematical debates, it could suggest stagnation in the field's progression. While controversies abound in sciences like physics and biology, mathematics seems to be distancing itself from such debates. This raises the question: Is this trend beneficial for the discipline's historical trajectory?

“Will history repeat itself?” While I cannot predict the future, I sincerely hope it does.

The first video title is A Brief History of Banned Numbers - Alessandra King - YouTube, which provides insight into the historical context and significance of banned numbers.

The second video title is Why the Number 0 Was Banned for 1500 Years - YouTube, which explores the cultural and mathematical implications of the number zero's prohibition.

If you wish to support my future content, consider contributing on Patreon.