My Experiences with Boundary Setting

I’ve either been a victim or perpetrator of unhealthy boundary setting:

• “This behavior is reminiscent of my ex.”
• “My grandmother used to give me the silent treatment; don’t do that to me.”
• “I’m not ready for you to meet my parents; my ex and my dad didn’t get along.”
• “My ex would interrupt me when I was focused, so keep that in mind.”

These statements won’t win anyone over. Constantly reminding your partner of how their behavior mirrors that of your ex does not cultivate love or respect.

The underlying message here is clear:

You haven’t moved on from your ex.

If you were truly over them, you wouldn’t bring them into your new relationship discussions. While referencing past relationships occasionally is normal, using an ex as a benchmark for boundaries is not healthy.

When I’ve dated women who relied on comparisons to exes or toxic family members to define what is acceptable, I found it hard to take them seriously. Communication that resembles high school drama is unappealing.

Why Moving On Matters

Every relationship is distinct. If you’re not careful, you might find yourself repeating the same mistakes with different partners. Those with unresolved emotional issues often unknowingly enter similar relationships, just with new faces.

Nevertheless, I’ve also experienced the contrasting dynamics in relationships, as if life was nudging me toward greater empathy and understanding. While patterns may emerge, it’s important to remember that no two individuals are identical. Our past relationships shape our identities and behaviors uniquely.

Your current partner is not your previous lover unless you enjoy rehashing the same dynamics. Being unable to move on from an ex suggests:

• Inflexibility: Inflexible individuals struggle to adapt to new situations. They fail to recognize that past experiences need not dictate present circumstances.
• Unreasonableness: Using an ex as a reference point for boundaries raises concerns about what else they might be closed to. Emotionally mature individuals consider everyone’s needs when establishing limits.
• Judgment: Past trauma can cloud judgment. If someone perceives your actions through the lens of their last partner, they may unfairly judge you based on incomplete information.
• Manipulation: Continually stating, “You remind me of my ex,” (especially negatively) can invoke feelings of fear and anxiety, damaging attraction and chemistry.

Those who haven’t moved on from former partners typically carry unresolved emotional baggage. Trauma can stem from various sources, not just romantic relationships; many originate in childhood.

As mentioned, I’ve observed individuals using their abusive family members as justification for boundaries with uninvolved parties. If you or your partner find yourselves fixating on past relationship issues, it likely indicates that trauma is at play.

To paraphrase Gabor Maté's The Myth of Normal: Trauma, Illness and Healing in a Toxic Culture, emotional trauma manifests as an injury—a scar that may either be tough or a fresh wound causing ongoing pain. Trauma distorts our perceptions and compels us to react to life rather than to live in the present, limiting our potential and often leading us to engage in behaviors that avoid pain.

How to Let Go of Past Relationship Baggage

Addressing past relationship trauma is crucial for embracing a healthy new relationship.

It’s a process that takes time, and there’s no universal timeline. Based on my experiences, it took me about 12 to 14 months to move on from a significant 4.5-year relationship. The nature of the relationship—being engaged and living together—made the breakup particularly challenging.

While I’ve advocated for getting back into dating soon after, it’s also important to prioritize healing. Casual dating can be beneficial but may distract from necessary emotional processing.

Taking a break can provide an opportunity to reassess personal goals and challenges.

Here are some practices that have been beneficial for me:

• Remain single for a brief period (1 to 3 months): Avoid using this time to fill the void left by your ex with others or distractions. Reflection on the mistakes made in the past relationship is essential.
• Stop fixating on their faults: Reflect on your own mistakes and consider your attachment style. It’s easy to label an ex as a narcissist without examining your own actions and how they contributed to relationship dynamics.
• Consider therapy if necessary: Therapy can be a powerful tool if you are willing to engage fully. Understanding your patterns can facilitate growth and healing.
• Embrace the process of letting go: Letting go requires emotional readiness. It involves developing a healthy relationship with your feelings, accepting all emotions, and avoiding distractions from grief.

Allow Others to Be Themselves

Recognizing that we are all unique individuals is vital. While it's important to be aware of potential negative behavior, projecting insecurities onto your partner is unfair and stunts growth in the relationship.

Boundaries exist to protect everyone involved. It’s unproductive to use past relationships or family members as justification for boundaries that may not be warranted.

— Paul Trood

If you appreciated this article and are interested in personal growth, consider subscribing to my weekly newsletter.