Understanding Why We Get Defensive When Reading Opinions
Written on
Chapter 1 The Nature of Defensive Reactions
In my experience, I've penned a few pieces that might be seen as provocative. However, what often goes unnoticed is that when readers become emotionally charged by my comments, it's usually a signal that those remarks resonate with something they are sensitive about—whether they acknowledge it or not.
For instance, if I claim, "You're overweight because you overeat," a person who maintains a healthy weight will likely dismiss this statement without a second thought. It won’t faze them in the slightest, as they don't see themselves reflected in those words.
Conversely, someone who has struggled with their weight for years may react defensively to my assertion. This is particularly true if they suspect that there’s some truth in the statement and they haven't yet come to terms with their situation. On the other hand, a self-aware individual might recognize the validity of my comment without feeling the need to lash out.
Now, if a person knows their weight challenges stem from a medical issue, such as a hormonal imbalance, they might feel compelled to correct me, possibly leaving an irritated comment about my generalizations. The key takeaway is that there was something in the article that struck a chord with them, prompting their reaction in the first place.
Section 1.1 The Role of Self-Identification
When I write articles with bold claims, like this one, I often wonder about the reactions they'll provoke. If I come across a post that doesn't resonate with me, I'll likely scroll past it without investing time in a rebuttal.
While I might briefly skim it to assess its validity, I wouldn't typically spend my energy contesting the author's views unless I possess relevant insights that I feel compelled to share. Most often, I simply dismiss it and continue on my way.
In my article titled "Stop Pretending Men Have the Monopoly on 'Not Getting It'," I was taken aback by the number of men who felt the need to debate my points. It’s easy to find data supporting the idea that many women in relationships desire more intimacy, yet their partners might not be receptive.
Men's vocal expressions of misunderstanding often overshadow the silent struggles of women. This, I argued, stems from historical treatment of women, resulting in less entitlement regarding sexual satisfaction compared to men.
Section 1.2 The Surprising Pushback
I was genuinely surprised by the backlash I received. It became clear that many of these men were reacting defensively, perhaps because they felt they were falling short in their relationships or were aware of their own entitled behaviors. Why else would they vehemently defend a stance that is relatively easy to refute?
Chapter 2 Reflecting on Your Reactions
The next time you find yourself stirred up by an article, take a moment to reflect on why someone else's opinion provokes such a strong response from you, especially if you deem it misguided. After all, it's just one person's perspective.
Writing is a passion of mine, and I sincerely appreciate you taking the time to read this. If you feel inclined, there's a link available to buy me a coffee as a token of appreciation.
Kate transformed her challenging past as a teenage welfare mother into a catalyst for education and success. Now a mother of four and a grandmother to two, she works as a Fund Accountant in alternative investments and shares insights on money, relationships, parenting, and life experiences through her blog.
If you found this article insightful, consider following Long After the Thrill of Living is Gone.