Is the Body Positivity Movement Losing Its Impact?
Written on
The Rise and Fall of Body Positivity
Reflecting on the early 2000s, many can recall a time when thinness was the ideal. During this period, the portrayal of women in media often leaned toward an unrealistic standard of beauty, exemplified by the super-slim Victoria's Secret models that dominated the scene.
"In the early 2000s, being thin was synonymous with beauty. The prevalence of emaciated models in media reinforced this narrative."
A significant turning point in my life came with the release of the film "The Duff" in 2015. This movie introduced the term 'designated ugly fat friend,' yet the character labeled as such, played by Mae Whitman, was far from overweight. Characters who were genuinely heavier, like Fat Amy in "Pitch Perfect," often served as comic relief, perpetuating the idea that being overweight was something to ridicule.
Throughout my childhood, I absorbed the critical self-talk of those around me, particularly my mother’s constant complaints about her weight. This negative self-image became ingrained in me, leading to similar thoughts about my own appearance, despite being of average weight.
The influence of social media platforms like Tumblr in the 2010s further complicated matters. While it offered a space for individuality, it still adhered to the dominant narrative that beauty equated to extreme thinness.
I was never technically overweight, but I struggled with body image issues and found myself entangled in the pro-anorexia (pro-ana) community online. Here, images of dangerously thin girls were glamorized, and harmful tips for ignoring hunger cues circulated widely.
Over time, my relationship with food became a cycle of deprivation and guilt. I often found myself unable to escape the relentless cycle of bingeing and purging, feeling ashamed and insecure about my body.
The Emergence of Body Positivity
Do you remember Meghan Trainor’s catchy song "All About That Bass"? Released in 2014, it celebrated diverse body types, yet it’s noteworthy that Trainor herself wasn’t overweight; she represented a typical body image for her demographic.
The 2010s ushered in a wave of body positivity, with figures like Tess Holliday advocating for more representation in fashion through movements such as #effyourbeautystandards. Lizzo, despite not achieving immediate success, became a household name with her empowering messages about self-love.
Jennifer Lawrence also stood out as a celebrity who refused to conform to the pressure to lose weight for her role in "The Hunger Games," stating, “I don’t want little girls to be like, ‘Oh, I want to look like Katniss, so I’m going to skip dinner.’”
However, even as body positivity gained traction, societal standards began shifting again. The emergence of the "slim thick" aesthetic, largely popularized by the Kardashian family, introduced new beauty ideals that still left many women feeling inadequate.
Are we regressing in our journey toward body acceptance?
The recent popularity of medications like Ozempic for weight loss, despite not being FDA-approved for such use, raises questions about our collective progress. Social media trends reflecting self-deprecating humor about eating habits seem to indicate a return to previous norms regarding body image.
Moreover, the fashion industry appears to be reverting to traditional ideals, with models returning to the “skinny” look amid economic pressures.
Recent controversies have also emerged around figures like Lizzo, who faced backlash for allegedly body shaming her dancers, contradicting her previous advocacy for body positivity.
This shift in societal attitudes raises the question: are we moving backward in our acceptance of diverse body types?
The Shift in Online Communities
While I no longer engage with pro-eating disorder content on social media, I hear that it has evolved. The focus has shifted from self-hatred to targeting others, with a new trend called 'fatspo' emerging, which promotes body shaming.
Victoria’s Secret's attempts at rebranding, highlighted in the documentary "Victoria’s Secret: Angels and Demons," showcased models who defied traditional beauty standards. However, this change was short-lived, as the company reverted to its original marketing strategy, suggesting that consumer trust in corporate sincerity is fleeting.
The Reality of Capitalism and Body Image
The fashion industry's continual cycle of praising and shaming various body types is nothing new. Historical trends have fluctuated between extremes of body size, highlighting the transient nature of societal beauty standards.
While self-acceptance could theoretically diminish profit margins in the beauty and fashion sectors, these industries thrive on insecurity. Trends emerge to keep consumers in a loop of constant consumption—whether it’s new clothing, diet products, or beauty enhancements.
In reflecting on body positivity, Meghan Trainor's lyrics remind us that preferences vary widely; not everyone will find the same traits attractive.
Ultimately, I advocate for body neutrality over body positivity; it allows us to appreciate our bodies without the pressure of societal standards. Our bodies belong to us, regardless of external validation.
The Body Positivity Movement is NOT Positive - This video critiques the body positivity movement, discussing how it may not be as beneficial as it seems.
The Body Positivity Movement Is Not So Positive Anymore... - This video explores the current state of body positivity and its evolving challenges.