Death and the Ethics of Human Remains in Modern Culture
Written on
Chapter 1: The Quest for Charles Byrne's Remains
In June 1783, a group of bounty hunters surrounded the home of Charles Byrne. Armed with harpoons and eager to claim their prize, they were not after Byrne alive; he had succumbed to gin and tuberculosis at just 22 years old. Instead, these hunters sought to capture his skeletal remains.
Byrne's towering height of 7'7" made him a subject of fascination. He had journeyed from Ireland to London, hoping that his size would bring him fame. By the next year, he had become a celebrity, captivating audiences in Piccadilly and Charing Cross as the "Irish Giant."
Despite his popularity, Byrne feared that upon his death, his body would be subjected to dissection, and he took measures to prevent this, even paying for a burial at sea. Unfortunately, his wishes were ignored, and his remains were auctioned off to the renowned surgeon John Hunter for £130. Hunter then preserved Byrne's skeleton, which became a centerpiece in his private museum, eventually moving to the Hunterian Museum in London in 1799, where it remains on display.
Byrne's story took a scientific turn in 2009 when DNA extracted from his teeth revealed a rare genetic mutation, leading to a pituitary tumor and acromegaly—a condition that causes excessive growth due to surplus growth hormone. Sadly, this condition brought Byrne considerable pain throughout his life, often alleviated through alcohol. In 2020, author Hilary Mantel urged for Byrne's final wishes to be respected, and in 2023, following public outcry, the Hunterian Museum removed his skeleton from public view, although the remains are still held for "further research."
The video titled "Why are there human remains in Disney's Haunted Mansion?" delves into the complex relationship between entertainment and the ethical considerations of using human remains in popular culture.
Section 1.1: The Disrespect of Albert Einstein's Remains
One of the most notorious instances of disrespecting the dead involves Albert Einstein. He had requested that his body be cremated and his ashes scattered, but during his autopsy, his remains were dissected for study. His eyes were given to his eye doctor, while parts of his heart and liver were distributed among medical students. The most infamous part of his remains, his brain, was cut into pieces and stored by Dr. Thomas Harvey, who later sent samples to various neurologists for research.
Today, parts of Einstein's brain can be found at the Mütter Museum in Philadelphia, displayed alongside other curiosities, raising ethical questions about the treatment of human remains after death.
Section 1.2: The Use of Human Remains in Entertainment
Disney is not alone in using real human remains for entertainment. The cult classic movie Poltergeist featured actual skeletons in a scene that disturbed actress JoBeth Williams upon learning the truth. Similarly, t